OnePlus 5 review: Ignore the hate, this phone is awesome

Posted:  July 25, 2017   By:    26 comments   


Getting the fundamentals absolutely right

With all the “chatter” surrounding the OnePlus 5, I think it’s only fair that we begin this review by addressing some of them and we’ll start with the benchmark cheating.

For me, the uproar that followed the revelation that OnePlus had cheated in benchmark tests was rather surprising. I thought that we had progressed past solely relying on synthetic benchmark tests to judge the worth of a smartphone but judging from the flak I got for this article, it turns out I was wrong.

Or so I thought. Examining the outrage a little closer, I found that many weren’t so much upset with the results of the cheating, but rather they were pissed at the fact that OnePlus broke their trust. And that’s completely understandable.

I can’t begin to try and explain why OnePlus did what they did but I can tell you that the OnePlus 5 is definitely one of the best performing Android smartphones in the market right now. This model I have here features a Snapdragon 835 processor, 6GB of RAM and 64GB of UFS 2.1 storage. Last year, I said that the word “immediate” was designed to describe the OnePlus 3’s performance and that is still very much the case for the OnePlus 5.

It’s ridiculously speedy. The OnePlus 5 doesn’t waste time with lengthy animations or “smoothness”. Everything happens immediately and that’s really awesome. Though, speediness isn’t the only thing OnePlus carried over to the 5. This new flagship also has the company’s excellent Oxygen OS UI built on top of Android 7.1.1 Nougat which is awesome for anyone who loves the stock Android experience.

However, I really can’t talk about usability without also touching on the next big issue people have with the OnePlus 5 — the jelly scrolling effect.

Apparently a byproduct of OnePlus mounting their screen upside down, the jelly scrolling effect is definitely something you can spot if you’re looking for it. However, when I handed the OnePlus 5 to my colleagues and friends who weren’t actively looking for the jelly effect, none of them noticed it until I started pointing it out to them. Even then, they didn’t feel that it was a really big problem and some even thought it was a nice animation. Although I don’t agree with it being a nice animation, I also don’t think that it’s really a big deal. It took my brain about three days to get used to and completely ignore it.

Performance, then, is as much a pro for the OnePlus 5 as it was for the phone it succeeds — not to mention the fact that its lightning quick fingerprint scanner also carries over. That said, last year’s speed and fluidity came at a cost: Battery life was abysmal. This time, I’m happy to report that the OnePlus 5 has pretty much fixed that problem.

With this new device, I’m averaging just shy of four and half hours of screen on time (SOT) (moderate usage) with at least 12 hours on battery. That’s an hour and a half better SOT than my average with the OnePlus 3. If my usage gets a little heavier (lots of camera and navigation), that drops closer to four hours.

And the best part is that OnePlus did all that without compromising on charging speed. With Dash Charge, I managed to top up the OnePlus 5’s 3,300 mAh battery from 5% in about one and a half hours. 30 minutes on the plug gave me about a 60% charge.

But internals aren’t the only thing OnePlus improved with the 5. They also did an excellent job on the smartphone’s body. Its this nice sexy metal shell that’s curvy in all the right places for a really nice fit in the hand.

I will admit that when I first saw it in photos, I thought the phone looked exactly like an iPhone 7 Plus clone but when you see it in real life, it actually doesn’t bear that much of a resemblance. Of course, to the untrained eye, people are probably going to mistake it for an iPhone, but then again I’ve had people mistake the HTC 10 for an iPhone too.

Personally, I like the design and feel of the phone. It feels like a step up from the 3 and 3T in terms of quality though the sleeker form does make this phone super slippery. I’d recommend getting a case or a skin for better grip.

Now, we’ll move on to the next “issue” with the OnePlus 5 — its camera. When the phone was launched, there was a lot of emphasis being placed on camera performance, and rightfully so, since the camera was always a big weakness with the phones that “Never Settle”.

This time, OnePlus has built a fancy dual-camera system (the hardware from OPPO’s R11) that features a 16-megapixel f/1.7 aperture wide-angle camera with a 20-megapixel f/2.6 aperture telephoto shooter. They called it the highest resolution dual-camera system in a smartphone today, but is it the best?

Well, the short answer is “not really”. Compared to the juggernauts in the smartphone photography industry like Samsung’s Galaxy S8, the iPhone 7 Plus and the HTC U11, to name a few, I don’t feel that the OnePlus 5 can topple any one of them.

I will say this, though, the 5’s camera is definitely the best one I’ve ever used on a OnePlus flagship smartphone. Launching and snapping images was smooth and fast. Autofocusing was mostly accurate and snappy. And image quality is plenty good enough to post to your social feeds.

Throughout my review, I didn’t find myself wishing I had a better smartphone camera when I was shooting events and other daily things.

Low-light performance did leave some to be desired and the lack of OIS means you will have to hold still during dark scenes or you’ll end up with photos like these:

I also tested the OnePlus 5’s “Portrait” mode pretty extensively and I found that it produces usable images…most of the time. Sometimes it would just flat out refuse to detect a face (it doesn’t work in low light), or it would incorrectly blur sections of my subject for no apparent reason, but for the most part it works.

Yes, the bokeh doesn’t look particularly realistic. In fact, it looks really digital and not at all like it came out of a proper camera but then again no smartphone’s “bokeh effect” looks very realistic. Once I got over that fact, the portrait/depth-of-field mode actually became a lot of fun and photography is always better when it’s fun.

It adds a little pizzazz to spice up otherwise mundane photographs and I like that.

By now, I think I’ve addressed most of the “big concerns” surrounding the smartphone and what we’re left with is a handset that’s more than just “pretty good”. It’s actually a really cohesive flagship smartphone experience with the chops to rub shoulders with any of the big boys.

But, because of the way OnePlus is, as a company, they do have their hands tied when it comes to some of the other big features you might have seen on flagships bearing Samsung, Apple or LG’s badge.

There is no eye-popping edge-to-edge 18.5:9 aspect ratio screen. There are no high-tech stereo speakers or squeezable sides. There is no MIL STD 810G durability resistance. And there is no water resistance of any kind — which to me, is the most inconvenient of them all.

However, because of that, you can buy the OnePlus 5 for as low as RM2,388 for this 6GB RAM/64GB storage model in Slate Gray or get the RM2,688 8GB RAM/128GB storage variant. Yes, it’s more pricey than the OnePlus 3 and 3T but I think it’s has made enough of an improvement to justify it.

And I’m not just talking about the big stuff like its battery life, camera or specs, I also really loved the new vibration motor. On most phones, the vibration is too loud (not to mention it makes an ugly sound) yet not quite strong enough. On the OnePlus 5, it’s soft (almost muted) yet strong, which makes it the best one I’ve ever used.

I have thoroughly enjoyed my time with the OnePlus 5 and I will once again recommend a OnePlus phone to anyone looking for the best bang-for-your-buck Android flagship.


Android, Mobile Devices, Mobile OS, OnePlus, Product review
, , , , , , , ,
Wanna say something?






 

26 Comments for OnePlus 5 review: Ignore the hate, this phone is awesome

Hak

You forgot to include in the bad list on the inverted display that led to some obvious/less obvious jelly effect. I have to disagree on oneplus 5 being worth the extra for the buck compared to the predecessor. I had the OP3T and now the OP5, forget about the numbers on Antutu, these guys perform seemingly the same or not, just micro differences. Is the OP5 worth it as an upgrade from OP3T? The answer is no. At least the OP3T has OIS. The OP3T is still a better buck for your money guys.

    LOL

    Someone didn’t read and jump to conclusions.

      Hak

      I did read it. You just didn't understand that I was referring to the summary of the bad list and not what was mentioned in the article. The OIS should be on the bad list too, funny that it isn't, rather, "Absurdly slippery" is when the obvious missing OIS is a more crucial negative compared to the prior.

        YKK

        I am also puzzled. To me, it's like saying "Ignore the ugliness, she's pretty". So everyone is pretty then.

    Hong

    Jelly effect doesn't happen on mine, OIS for better exposure (not to mention stabilisation which EIS also did a great job) and it doesn't feel that much of a difference. Not worth for an upgrade from OP3T, if older than that then its worth every penny.

      Hak

      OIS and EIS have clear differences tho. EIS crops the video image to compensate for the movement while OIS which uses hardware doesn't, therefore you get the full frame. So, no image degradation as necessary compensations. The better is always OIS.

      But if the OP5 is not much of an upgrade from the OP3T (Which I own both from experience of comparing), you might as well buy OP3T which is cheaper and forget about the 8GB variant (which I'm using), you will never use up that much ram. It's pure gimmick. I mean OP is a good phone in general and still consider cheap as a flagship but considering it as an upgrade from its predecessor and the added price bump is ridiculous.

HP. Enthusiast

I’m not surprise at all that this phone is hated from many aspects, Soyacincau had stated it here, no need elaboration.

The pricing of the phone is not even listed on the list of comparison between “The Good” nor “The Bad” as it is no longer a flagship without ‘breaking a bank’ price tag. BBK Electronics has now became a mad cow.

Its predecessors were missed a lot by many until they were dubbed as ‘flagship killer’ in the past.

I love an article about ” “$400 Flagship” is dead”, equivalent with “Flagship Killer has been dead, hail Samsung and Apple”.

Shutterbeach

Omitting OIS (Optical Image Stabilization) is the biggest blunder in ANY flagship smartphone.

OIS just simply works. Period. Full stop. EIS (Electronic/Software Optical Stabilization) that they are
using in 1+5 resulted a horrendous efx (look up vids samples/reviews in YT).

You need Deep Blue level of AI to compensate hundreds if not thousand of scenarios to counter
shakes (especially in low light condition).

So unless manufacturers can figure out cramming super-computer level of processors in a smartphone,
best to stick to OIS & improve noise reduction algorithm.

Remember… when even the infamous over-charging Apple/Iphone uses OIS… then we know best
not be a cheapskate & use industrial proven solution.

    Hong

    Only benefit in OIS compared to EIS is OIS allow better exposure in low light situation. Stabilisation wise both do a great job. I'm using 1+5 for a week + now and i can clearly tell you that they have superior stabilisation. Phone now days doesn't rely on spec sheets anymore.

    Don't follow the herds, sheepsssssssss …

Jerry

What a retarded person

qwerty

better get honor 8 pro, samsung C9 pro or upcoming honor 9. those can get cheaper at online store. better have a great customer service than a CEO dodging every flaws.

tommy

S7 edge is better. 4GB RAM is sufficient. Camera spec superior with OIS.

    iawnaek

    My colleague just bought the S7 edge for Rm2300 plus from DirectD.

    Hak

    It is! I had the S7 edge and OP5. The camera was so much better on the last year's flagship, S7 edge. OP5 has the better selfie camera tho.

Elixir

No hate, if on the right selling price.

Below RM 1500 for a scandal phone should be acceptable.

    Teatech

    If u can make myr to usd to about rm2 for $1 usd, then there will be rm1500 or less

      Elixir

      His job to do it.

      Finance Minister get pay by tax payer to do the job.

      Ask him would be more appropriate.

isengard12

Overrated phone really. Although the price vs specs is good on paper.

tosh

I have just upgraded from my Oneplus One bought in 2014 to the Oneplus 5.
And I am happy and satisfied with the phone although it took quite some time to come to a decision.
For that amount of money, one should be quite contented. Of course, some may prefer the
other brands. It's a matter of preference. As for the Oneplus 5, it's a near perfect phone for me.

JackL

Hype or not, OP5 is a very good phone. I bought one last week and im very satisfied. People that care more for brand can top up a bit and get s7 edge but I think this is worth paying for bloatware free android and fast performance. My previous phone is nexus 6p. People who say S8 or iP7 is fast should try OP5 first then you know what people are talking about.

mutusamy

it isnt a few hundred extra…its nearly a thousand extra from what i paid for OP3….

    Hong

    it was because of your sloppy currency rate, not that much on actual price hike.

      mutusamy

      what exchange rate…when OP3 came out the MYR is already hell banknote

Butahuruf

Those who bought the pH will have to live with it sucks or not lol might as well say good lo else seksa XD pity u guys

iawnaek

I don't hate the OnePlus 5, I just won't buy it that's all.

Teksi Drebar

I own both Samsung S7 and now OP5. I love OP5 for what it is. I cannot replicate the jelly effect or at least I didn’t notice its existence having used it for around 2 weeks now. It is super fast and clean. Going to use it for the next 3 years and then move on to something else. The fight for which smartphone is the best or worth the money is never-ending. There is always the next upcoming one to be released and people would line up the phones for comparison again and again. Just settle for a phone that do the job for you at this point of time and move on until it is time for a replacement.